§ 23 EStG Statement · 5 October 2026

Response to the draft bill: measure first, then decide

On 5 October 2026 Matthias Steger submitted a statement to the German Federal Ministry of Finance on the draft law reforming the taxation of certain crypto assets held as private assets (draft status 30 September 2026). Its core message: keep section 23 EStG, build enforcement on the new reporting instruments, and decide on a change of system only once the first reports have been evaluated.

Full text: the statement with all requests, 23 pages, in German. Statement as PDF ↓
In short
  • Recommendation: keep section 23 EStG; build enforcement on DAC8, CARF, the Transfer of Funds Regulation and the AML Regulation. Decide on a system change only after the first reports are evaluated.
  • In the alternative: if the ministry keeps the withholding system, regulate minimum requirements, above all a fallback basis of at most 30 per cent instead of 50 per cent.
  • The draft identifies no enforcement deficit in the current section 23 EStG and examines no alternative ("Alternatives: none").
  • Thirteen requests, from a special evaluation of Annex SO to a statutory review after three years.

The core message in three steps

The statement is about even enforcement. It is written for the ministry, in German; this page summarises it for readers who live in Germany.

The proposal in three steps
StepProposal
1. RecommendationKeep section 23 EStG. Build enforcement on DAC8/KStTG, CARF, the Transfer of Funds Regulation and the AML Regulation (verification instead of a flat withholding tax). Measure first, then decide.
2. In the alternativeIf the ministry keeps the withholding system: minimum requirements so that the withholding is designed for enforcement, including proportionate cover of the tax on swaps and a proof procedure for transfers to your own wallets.
3. In any caseTreat stablecoins and e-money tokens like foreign currency, clarify individual provisions, run a special evaluation of Annex SO as the baseline for the revenue estimate, examine alternatives and compliance costs, allow twelve months\' lead time for ordinances and interfaces, and review the law after three years against indicators.

The yardstick is the case law of the Federal Constitutional Court: where the assessment of a tax depends on the taxpayer\'s declaration, the declaration principle has to be supplemented by verification (decision of 27 June 1991, 2 BvR 1493/89). For section 23 EStG the Federal Fiscal Court found no structural enforcement deficit in 2023 (judgment of 14 February 2023, IX R 3/22), pointing to collective information requests and the OECD Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework.

The statement raises six enforcement concerns: the withholding would cover only domestic providers; it can have the effect of a final tax without anyone having verified the cost basis; the 50 per cent fallback basis (30 per cent for securities) pushes users out of the system; whether a holding is old or new cannot be checked from reporting data; losses can be realised without giving up the position; and enforcement shifts to the state tax offices, for whose effort the draft contains only the placeholder "[to follow]".

The worked example

Sale for €40,000, cost €38,000, gain €2,000.

Tax withheld by basis (25% tax, 5.5% solidarity surcharge)
BasisTaxable basisTax 25%Surcharge 5.5%Total withheld
Actual gain€2,000€500.00€27.50€527.50
Fallback, securities (30%)€12,000€3,000.00€165.00€3,165.00
Fallback, draft (50%)€20,000€5,000.00€275.00€5,275.00
The deduction exceeds the tax owed tenfold

The difference is only refunded in the tax assessment (section 32d(4) EStG), some time after the sale. The statement expects that users would then move to providers outside the withholding system or to self-custody.

What it means for you

Nothing changes today: the draft is not law, and the cabinet did not take it up on 14 October 2026; it is now due to discuss the bill on 9 December 2026 (BTC-ECHO, 17 November 2026).

  • Keep purchase dates and cost bases for every tranche. Without proof, the draft would apply the 50 per cent fallback basis, and your holding could not be shown to be an old one.
  • If you move between providers, ask for the acquisition data; the statement asks for this to become a legal duty.
  • Self-custody: keep the wallet history. The statement proposes a legal proof procedure for transfers to your own wallets, based on the data collected under the Transfer of Funds Regulation and the AML Regulation.
  • The statement also asks that a mismatch between reporting data and your return first triggers a query, not a finding of intent or gross negligence.

For the draft itself, see our article on the draft bill; for the rules in force today, the holding period and DAC8.

Questions and answers

What does the statement ask for, in short?
It recommends keeping section 23 of the Income Tax Act (EStG) and strengthening enforcement through DAC8, CARF, the Transfer of Funds Regulation and the AML Regulation: "measure first, then decide". In the alternative, if the legislature keeps the withholding system, it proposes minimum requirements, among them a fallback basis of at most 30 per cent.
Why is the 50 per cent fallback basis a problem?
Where no usable data exist, the draft assumes an acquisition after 31 December 2026 and withholds on 50 per cent of the proceeds; for securities the figure is 30 per cent. In the statement's example (sale for €40,000, cost €38,000, gain €2,000) €5,275 would be withheld although €527.50 is owed. The difference is only refunded in the tax assessment.
Does this affect crypto I already hold?
The statement welcomes the draft's grandfathering of existing holdings. It points out, however, that whether something is an old or a new holding is a fact neither the provider nor the tax office can verify from the reporting data. It therefore asks, among other things, for a statutory duty to pass on acquisition data when you change provider, and for a holdings report as at 31 December 2026.
Is this about a law or about a draft?
About the ministry draft (status 30 September 2026). It is not law. Until a law is promulgated, section 23 EStG with its one-year holding period applies. See our article on the draft bill.
Where can I read the full statement?
As a PDF (23 pages, in German): statement of 5 October 2026. It was addressed to the Federal Ministry of Finance, unit IV C 1.
Author: Matthias Steger, tax adviser, Potsdam.
Status: 13 October 2026. Basis is the statement of 5 October 2026 on the ministry draft (draft status 30 September 2026), PDF in German. This page is a shortened summary; the full text prevails.

Read on

TaxTobi, Illustration

Still have a question on this topic?

TaxTobi is our AI assistant for crypto tax under German law. It answers from a reviewed knowledge base with the legal basis and date, one question free. It does not give individual advice; for your own case, talk to us.